{"section":{"filename":"s811.html","chapter":"800","section_number":"811","title":"Time for Making Requirement","revision_tag":"R-07.2022","bytes":32357,"sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc","subsection_count":4,"max_depth":1,"subsections":[{"number":"811.01","title":"[Reserved]","revision_tag":null,"depth":1},{"number":"811.02","title":"New Requirement After Compliance With Preceding Requirement","revision_tag":"R-08.2012","depth":1},{"number":"811.03","title":"Repeating After Withdrawal Proper","revision_tag":"R-08.2012","depth":1},{"number":"811.04","title":"Proper Even Though Grouped Together in Parent Application","revision_tag":"R-08.2012","depth":1}]},"quality":"structured","cited_authorities":{"file_section":"811","cases":[{"key":"case:1904c.d.63","slug":"ex-parte-benke","short_name":"Ex parte Benke","canonical_citation":"Ex parte Benke, 1904 C.D. 63, 108 OG 1588 (Comm’r Pat. 1904)","decision_year":1904,"court":"Comm'r Pat.","holding_summary":"Because restriction is proper at any stage of prosecution up to final action, a second restriction requirement may be made when it becomes proper, even though the applicant complied with a prior requirement.","holding_confidence":"high","mentions":1,"propositions":[]}],"statutes":[{"key":"us_cfr:37:1.142","slug":"37-cfr-1-142","canonical_citation":"37 CFR 1.142","mentions":2}],"cross_references":[],"form_paragraphs":[]},"structured_data":{"nodes":[{"id":"se_czrgzvkn","node_type":"section","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/se_czrgzvkn","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"","rendered_text_plain":"","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106438","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"akn_urn":"/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811","canonical_url":"https://mpep.io/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811","section_number":"811","chapter":"800","depth":0,"title":"Time for Making Requirement","children_ids":["pb_qazs2dcz","pb_y7fzestf","se_yuhrdavm","se_ujp7zqlq","se_56iqfcub","se_b5loudxo"],"revision_tag":"R-07.2022"},{"id":"pb_qazs2dcz","node_type":"prose_block","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/pb_qazs2dcz","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"<p id=\"d0e106442\"><b><a href=\"mpep-9020-appx-r.html#d0e324111\">37 CFR\n                              1.142(a)</a></b>, second sentence, indicates that a restriction requirement\n                        “will normally be made before any action upon the merits; however, it may be made at any\n                        time before final action.” This means the examiner should make a proper requirement as\n                        early as&nbsp;possible&nbsp;in the prosecution, in the first action if possible, otherwise, as soon\n                        as the need for a proper requirement develops.\n                     </p>","rendered_text_plain":"37 CFR 1.142(a), second sentence, indicates that a restriction requirement “will normally be made before any action upon the merits; however, it may be made at any time before final action.” This means the examiner should make a proper requirement as early as possible in the prosecution, in the first action if possible, otherwise, as soon as the need for a proper requirement develops.","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106442","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"kind":"narrative","host_section_id":"se_czrgzvkn"},{"id":"pb_y7fzestf","node_type":"prose_block","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/pb_y7fzestf","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"<p id=\"d0e106454\">Before requiring restriction of claims previously examined on the merits,\n                        the examiner must consider whether there will be a serious search and/or examination burden\n                        if restriction is not required.\n                     </p>","rendered_text_plain":"Before requiring restriction of claims previously examined on the merits, the examiner must consider whether there will be a serious search and/or examination burden if restriction is not required.","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106454","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"kind":"narrative","host_section_id":"se_czrgzvkn"},{"id":"se_yuhrdavm","node_type":"section","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/se_yuhrdavm","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"","rendered_text_plain":"","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"ch800_d22413_16979_247","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"akn_urn":"/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811_01","canonical_url":"https://mpep.io/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811_01","section_number":"811.01","chapter":"800","depth":1,"title":"[Reserved]","children_ids":["pb_rpedfnlk"],"parent_section_id":"se_czrgzvkn"},{"id":"pb_rpedfnlk","node_type":"prose_block","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/pb_rpedfnlk","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"","rendered_text_plain":"","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"ch800_d24bfb_20d9b_a4","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"kind":"decorative","host_section_id":"se_yuhrdavm"},{"id":"se_ujp7zqlq","node_type":"section","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/se_ujp7zqlq","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"","rendered_text_plain":"","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106457","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"akn_urn":"/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811_02","canonical_url":"https://mpep.io/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811_02","section_number":"811.02","chapter":"800","depth":1,"title":"New Requirement After Compliance With Preceding Requirement","children_ids":["pb_uxtcbeyi"],"revision_tag":"R-08.2012","parent_section_id":"se_czrgzvkn"},{"id":"pb_uxtcbeyi","node_type":"prose_block","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/pb_uxtcbeyi","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"<p id=\"d0e106465\"> Since <b><a href=\"mpep-9020-appx-r.html#d0e324111\">37 CFR 1.142(a)</a></b> provides that\n                           restriction is proper at any stage of prosecution up to final action, a second\n                           requirement may be made when it becomes proper, even though there was a prior\n                           requirement with which applicant complied. <i>Ex parte Benke,</i> 1904 C.D.\n                           63, 108 OG 1588 (Comm’r Pat. 1904).\n                        </p>","rendered_text_plain":"Since 37 CFR 1.142(a) provides that restriction is proper at any stage of prosecution up to final action, a second requirement may be made when it becomes proper, even though there was a prior requirement with which applicant complied. Ex parte Benke, 1904 C.D. 63, 108 OG 1588 (Comm’r Pat. 1904).","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106465","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"kind":"narrative","host_section_id":"se_ujp7zqlq"},{"id":"se_56iqfcub","node_type":"section","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/se_56iqfcub","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"","rendered_text_plain":"","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106474","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"akn_urn":"/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811_03","canonical_url":"https://mpep.io/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811_03","section_number":"811.03","chapter":"800","depth":1,"title":"Repeating After Withdrawal Proper","children_ids":["pb_exkpzfyl"],"revision_tag":"R-08.2012","parent_section_id":"se_czrgzvkn"},{"id":"pb_exkpzfyl","node_type":"prose_block","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/pb_exkpzfyl","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"<p id=\"d0e106478\">Where a requirement to restrict is made and thereafter withdrawn as\n                           improper, if restriction becomes proper at a later stage in the prosecution, restriction\n                           may again be required.\n                        </p>","rendered_text_plain":"Where a requirement to restrict is made and thereafter withdrawn as improper, if restriction becomes proper at a later stage in the prosecution, restriction may again be required.","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106478","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"kind":"narrative","host_section_id":"se_56iqfcub"},{"id":"se_b5loudxo","node_type":"section","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/se_b5loudxo","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"","rendered_text_plain":"","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106495","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"akn_urn":"/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811_04","canonical_url":"https://mpep.io/akn/us/statement/manual/uspto/2024/mpep/eng@2024-02-29!sec_811_04","section_number":"811.04","chapter":"800","depth":1,"title":"Proper Even Though Grouped Together in Parent Application","children_ids":["pb_7lq7gs5r"],"revision_tag":"R-08.2012","parent_section_id":"se_czrgzvkn"},{"id":"pb_7lq7gs5r","node_type":"prose_block","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/pb_7lq7gs5r","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"<p id=\"d0e106499\">Even though inventions are grouped together in a requirement in a\n                           parent application, restriction or election among the inventions may be required in the\n                           divisional applications, if proper.\n                        </p>","rendered_text_plain":"Even though inventions are grouped together in a requirement in a parent application, restriction or election among the inventions may be required in the divisional applications, if proper.","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106499","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"kind":"narrative","host_section_id":"se_b5loudxo"},{"id":"st_q7ljtsk2","node_type":"statute","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/st_q7ljtsk2","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"","rendered_text_plain":"","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":null,"source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"authority":"us_cfr","authority_title_num":"37","authority_section_num":"1.142","subsection_path":["a"],"canonical_citation":"37 CFR 1.142(a)"},{"id":"cs_gargqs5k","node_type":"case","corpus_id":"mpep-e9r01-2024-html","opaque_url":"https://mpep.io/n/cs_gargqs5k","effective_range":{"start_revision":"R-07.2022","end_revision":null},"rendered_text_html":"","rendered_text_plain":"Ex parte Benke, 1904 C.D. 63, 108 OG 1588 (Comm’r Pat. 1904)","provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":null,"source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"},"short_name":"Ex parte Benke","canonical_citation":"Ex parte Benke, 1904 C.D. 63, 108 OG 1588 (Comm’r Pat. 1904)","all_citations":["1904 C.D. 63","108 OG 1588"],"decision_year":1904,"court":"Comm'r Pat.","holding_summary":null,"holding_reviewer":null}],"edges":[{"id":"e_gqic3hfs","edge_type":"cites-statute","source_id":"pb_qazs2dcz","target_id":"st_q7ljtsk2","properties":{"citation_text":"37 CFR 1.142(a)","specificity":"subsection","source_offset":{"start":0,"end":15}},"provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106442","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"}},{"id":"e_rdyy5j2b","edge_type":"cites-statute","source_id":"pb_uxtcbeyi","target_id":"st_q7ljtsk2","properties":{"citation_text":"37 CFR 1.142(a)","specificity":"subsection","source_offset":{"start":6,"end":21}},"provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106465","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"}},{"id":"e_5pygfjeh","edge_type":"cites-case","source_id":"pb_uxtcbeyi","target_id":"cs_gargqs5k","properties":{"citation_text":"Ex parte Benke, 1904 C.D. 63, 108 OG 1588 (Comm’r Pat. 1904)","source_offset":{"start":236,"end":250}},"provenance":{"source_file":"s811.html","source_anchor":"d0e106465","source_sha256":"bede60376b46695d7cdc8c538bf309fc304902672a47d1934298f1e095f185dc"}}]}}